Supermarket Own-Brand Crisps Named Better Than Walkers and McCoys

Getty Images

Salt and vinegar has a loyal fan base in this country, and lots of us have bought the same brand for years without giving it much thought. A blind taste test by the team at Metro has now put that habit under pressure, lining up eight packets against each other to see which one comes out on top. The winner costs just £1, while one of the most famous names on the shelf ended up in the bottom half of the table.

Tasters tried salt and vinegar crisps from Asda, Aldi, Lidl, Morrisons, M&S and Waitrose, alongside two big branded options from Walkers and McCoys. Nobody knew which one they were eating at the time, so there was no chance of a familiar logo swaying anyone. That matters more than you’d think, because most of us expect the pricier bag to taste nicer before we’ve even opened it.

Each product was marked out of 20 in five areas: appearance, texture, size, flavour, and value for money. Value was worked out using the price per 100g rather than the figure on the sticker, which keeps things fair when pack sizes differ so much. Adding those five marks together gave every entry a total out of 100, and the gap between first and last place turned out to be surprisingly wide.

Asda takes the crown for £1.

Asda

Top of the pile was Asda’s own multipack, which comes as six 25g bags for £1. That works out at 67p per 100g, so it’s cheap enough to keep in the cupboard for lunchboxes or a sofa snack. It scored 83 overall, putting it a clear 14 points ahead of its nearest rival, which is a big lead in a test like this.

The panel loved how sharp and tangy it was, with enough vinegar to make an impression without leaving your mouth stinging. The crunch was satisfying but not harsh, and the slices looked golden and even, earning 19 for both appearance and size. The one grumble was a slightly greasy aftertaste, which cost it a little on texture but did nothing to stop it winning.

Lidl wins on price and snap.

Second place went to Lidl, with a total of 69. Its pack costs 80p, or roughly 53p per 100g, making it the cheapest choice in the whole line-up and earning it a perfect 20 for value. If keeping the weekly shop down is your main aim, this is the one to grab.

@minimunchreviews SnakTastic Salt and Vinegar Crisps #snaktastic #salt #vinegar #crisps #foodtok ♬ Ballerina – Yehezkel Raz

Flavour-wise, it held its own with a nice vinegary kick, and several judges thought it had the best crunch of the lot. What held it back was size, since the pieces were small and scored just 9 in that category. Reviewers also admitted that while they enjoyed eating them, they probably wouldn’t go out of their way to buy them again.

McCoys and Morrisons battle it out in the middle.

McCoys finished third on 68.5, making it the best-performing big brand. Its ridged, crinkle-cut shape went down well, earning a brilliant 19 for texture, and the colour looked appealing too. Where it fell short was on seasoning, as most people wanted a stronger vinegar hit than it managed to deliver.

Cost was an even bigger sticking point. At £1.57 per 100g, McCoys was easily the most expensive product tested, and it picked up only 2.5 for value as a result. Morrisons came in just behind on 67.5, priced at £1.10 a pack or 73p per 100g. Its slices were a bit pale and uneven, but the tang was pleasant without going overboard, and one taster liked that no two pieces looked alike.

It was a disappointing result for Walkers.

Walkers, the name most people picture when they think of crisps, managed only fifth place with 61.5. It did fine on looks, texture and size, landing somewhere in the middle for each, and the panel enjoyed its earthy potato taste when it came through. For such a household name, though, finishing behind three supermarket versions is hardly a result to celebrate.

Walkers

The main issue was patchy seasoning. Some pieces were spot on, while others seemed to have skipped the flavouring altogether, and that inconsistency dragged its taste mark down to 10. At £1.35 a pack, or 90p per 100g, it was also the third priciest option, so shoppers are paying extra for something that couldn’t beat a £1 alternative.

Aldi struggled despite a low price tag.

Aldi landed sixth with 52.5. Much like Lidl, it did well on cost, collecting 17.5 for value at around 57p per 100g. Since the discount chain usually does pretty well in comparisons like this, the rest of its scores came as a bit of a shock.

The crisps were tiny and pale, with a few burnt-looking dark pieces mixed in. Several judges found them bland, and one thought they tasted stale, with a dry, crumbly bite. A flavour score of 6 out of 20 was the lowest in the entire test, which shows a bargain only goes so far if you don’t enjoy what’s inside the bag.

The posh supermarkets finished last.

M&S came seventh with 49, and at £1.20 per 100g it was the second most expensive entry. Texture and size were decent enough, but the seasoning let it down badly. Some slices tasted of nothing but salt, others had an oddly sweet vinegar edge, and a couple of people felt it was barely different from ready salted.

M&S

Waitrose sat at the bottom with 46. At 80p per 100g it isn’t outrageously priced, yet it scored poorly almost everywhere. Tasters struggled to pick out any vinegar at all, and the pieces were small and weak. For two shops that pride themselves on quality, it’s an awkward place to end up.

What to pick up next time you shop

For the best all-rounder, Asda’s £1 multipack is hard to beat, as it did well on taste, appearance, and size while staying kind to your wallet. Lidl makes sense if price is your top concern and you don’t mind smaller pieces. McCoys suits anyone who loves a thick crinkle-cut crunch and is happy to pay more for it.

Taste is personal, of course, and one panel won’t match everybody’s opinion. It’s an easy experiment to try at home, though. Pick up a couple of own-brand packets, tip them into unlabelled bowls and see which one your family empties first. You might end up saving a bit every week without missing the branded bag at all.