Tesco Finest Roast Potatoes Top Good Housekeeping Christmas Taste Test

Getty Images/iStockphoto

Plenty of us still peel and parboil a mountain of potatoes on Christmas morning, but lots of people pick up a bag of ready-made roasties instead to free up time and oven space. If you’re thinking of doing the same this year, the Good Housekeeping Institute has just named its favourite, and it’s an own-brand pack from Tesco. Its testers tried ready-made roast potatoes from the big supermarkets and brands, and the winner costs £3.30. Here’s how the test worked, how the different packs compare on price, and how to cook, time and store them so they turn out well on the day.

The Good Housekeeping Institute’s panel of experts and consumers tasted the potatoes blind, so they didn’t know which supermarket each batch came from. Every product was cooked following the instructions on its own packaging, which means the results reflect what you’d get at home if you did the same.

The testers marked each one out of 100, looking for a good crunch, a golden colour, a soft and fluffy middle and seasoning that wasn’t too much or too little. Those are worth keeping in mind whichever bag you end up buying because they’re the things that make the difference on the plate.

The winner and the runner-up

Tesco

Tesco Finest Roast Potatoes with Confit Garlic came out on top with a score of 84 out of 100. They cost £3.30 for an 800g bag and are seasoned with rosemary, parsley, and thyme as well as slow-cooked garlic. The testers liked their crisp, caramelised edges and fluffy centres, and said the garlic gave them a deeper flavour.

In second place was Morrisons The Best Goose Fat Roast Potatoes, which scored 82 out of 100 and cost £4 for 800g. The two were close, so if one of these supermarkets is nearer to you than the other, either looks a safe choice based on the test.

The others in the line-up

Good Housekeeping’s list of ready-made roast potatoes also included packs from Lidl, M&S, Aldi, Asda, COOK, Waitrose, Aunt Bessie’s and Sainsbury’s. The scores published for the test only cover the top two, so there’s no published mark to compare the rest against.

What you can compare is the price. Lidl’s Maris Piper roast potatoes with goose fat were £2.99 for 800g, M&S’s frozen roast potatoes were £3 for 800g, and Aldi’s Specially Selected wagyu beef fat roast potatoes were £3.29 for 800g. Asda’s Exceptional beef dripping roast potatoes were £2.98 for 800g, while Aunt Bessie’s Roasties were £2.50 for 600g.

How the prices compare per kilo

Pack sizes vary, so the price on the front of the bag doesn’t always tell you which is the better deal. Working it out per kilo, Asda, Lidl and M&S come out cheapest at around £3.73 to £3.75 a kilo, with Aldi, Tesco, and Aunt Bessie’s not far behind at around £4.11 to £4.17. Morrisons works out at £5 a kilo.

At the other end, Sainsbury’s wagyu beef fat roast potatoes cost £8 for a 1 kg bag, COOK’s are £3.95 for 400g, which is close to £9.90 a kilo, and Waitrose No.1 wagyu beef roast potatoes are £6 for 600g, or £10 a kilo. Prices can change in the run-up to Christmas, so it’s worth checking the unit price on the shelf label or the supermarket’s app, which shows the cost per kilo for you.

Make sure you follow the pack instructions.

The Food Standards Agency advises following the cooking instructions on the pack when you cook packaged foods such as chips and roast potatoes. That’s also how the Good Housekeeping testers cooked every product, so sticking to the instructions gives you the best chance of matching the results.

Check whether your bag is meant to go in the oven from frozen or from chilled, as the times and temperatures differ. It’s worth reading the back of the pack when you buy it, rather than on Christmas morning, so you know how long they’ll need and can plan around it.

Aim for golden, not dark brown.

The Food Standards Agency also suggests aiming for a golden yellow colour or lighter when you roast starchy foods like potatoes. Cooking them until they’re very dark brown or burnt increases a chemical called acrylamide, which the agency advises keeping down where you can.

So rather than leaving roasties in for extra time to make them crunchier, keep an eye on them towards the end and take them out once they’re golden. Spreading them out in a single layer on the tray, with a little space between each one, usually helps them crisp evenly without needing longer in the oven.

Fitting them in around the turkey is something of an art.

Oven space is often the biggest headache on Christmas Day, and ready-made roast potatoes can help because they usually need less time than cooking them from scratch. Many people cook theirs while the turkey is resting after it comes out of the oven, which frees up the shelf space and lets you turn the oven up to the temperature on the potato pack.

Writing a simple timetable working back from when you want to eat can save a lot of stress. Note when the turkey needs to come out, when the potatoes need to go in and anything else that needs the oven, so nothing ends up waiting or going cold.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Poppy O’Toole (@poppy_cooks)

How to store them safely

If you buy frozen roast potatoes early, keep them in the freezer until you need them and check the use-by or best-before date on the bag. The Food Standards Agency says once food has been defrosted it should be cooked and eaten within 24 hours and not refrozen, so only take out what you plan to use.

For leftovers, the agency says to cool cooked food and put it in the fridge within one to two hours, and to eat leftovers within 48 hours or freeze them if that won’t be possible. Your fridge should be between 0C and 5C. If you’re reheating leftovers that have been frozen, make sure they’re steaming hot all the way through.

A few things to remember about potatoes

The NHS says potatoes don’t count towards your 5 A Day because they’re a starchy food, although parsnips, swedes, and turnips do. So if you’re serving roast potatoes, adding a few other vegetables to the plate is an easy way to get some of your portions in on the day.

The NHS also says potatoes are a healthy choice when they’re roasted with only a small amount of fat or oil and no added salt. Many ready-made roasties already come coated in fat and seasoning, so you usually won’t need to add more before they go in the oven.