No Quality Street at John Lewis This Year as Pick and Mix Is Axed

Getty Images

For many households, a tub of chocolates is as much a part of Christmas as the tree and the crackers. Some families stay loyal to Cadbury Roses or Heroes, while others always reach for Celebrations, but Quality Street remains one of the nation’s best-loved festive treats. This year, though, Quality Street fans are facing a couple of big changes. The chocolates themselves are staying the same, but a much-loved way of buying them is disappearing, and a recent packaging trial has been brought to an end. Here’s what’s changing and what it means for your Christmas shopping.

Since 2018, John Lewis has run a special Quality Street Pick and Mix station in its stores every Christmas. Shoppers could fill their own boxes with their favourite sweets, leaving out the ones that usually end up abandoned at the bottom of the tub.

This year, for the first time in eight years, the department store has confirmed it won’t be offering the service. Many fans have taken to social media to share their disappointment, with some saying the Pick and Mix had become a festive tradition in their family.

There’s no Quality Street at John Lewis this year at all.

It’s not only the Pick and Mix that’s missing, as John Lewis won’t be selling any Quality Street products at all this Christmas. A message on the retailer’s website confirms the chocolates won’t be available, pointing customers towards other gift options instead.

Shoppers looking for chocolate gifts at John Lewis can choose from brands such as Hotel Chocolat, Butlers and Tony’s Chocolonely. Quality Street tubs will still be widely available in supermarkets and other shops, so fans won’t have to go without.

Paper tubs are axed across the board.

The second change comes from Nestlé, the company that makes Quality Street. For the past two Christmases, it trialled paper tubs at Tesco as a more environmentally friendly alternative to the classic plastic tub. The paper tubs were decorated with gold foil to give them a special, luxurious look, and they could be fully recycled. However, Nestlé has confirmed that the paper tubs won’t be returning for Christmas 2026.

The paper tubs divided opinion when they first appeared in 2024. Some shoppers insisted the chocolates somehow didn’t taste the same, even though the sweets inside hadn’t changed at all. Others joked about what would happen to the old family tradition of reusing the tubs for storing buttons, sewing kits and odds and ends. Some fans felt it was one change too many, following the earlier switch from shiny plastic wrappers to paper ones on the individual sweets.

Although the paper tubs won’t be on shelves this year, Nestlé has hinted that they aren’t gone for good. The company says it’s using what it learned from the last two trials to make improvements to the design. It hopes to bring the paper tubs back on a bigger scale in the future. Many big brands are looking for ways to cut plastic packaging, so it’s likely more changes will come over the next few years.

Quality Street is a festive favourite with a long history.

@tonywarner_nostalgia Quality Street 2026 vs 1996 Trying my best to relive those 90s Christmas magic moments #childhoodmemories #90s #90sChristmas ♬ original sound – Tony Warner

Quality Street was first made in 1936 in Halifax, West Yorkshire, by the Mackintosh’s sweet company, which was later bought by Nestlé. The brightly wrapped sweets were designed to bring a touch of luxury to ordinary families at an affordable price.

Almost every household has its own views on the best and worst sweets in the tub. The Purple One is often named as a favourite, while others, such as the coconut-flavoured sweets, are famously left until last, which is why the Pick and Mix proved so popular.

There are still other ways to customise your chocolates.

If you liked choosing your own sweets, there are still other options this Christmas. Cadbury has launched a new online shop where fans can build their own box of Heroes, choosing exactly which chocolates go inside, with prices starting at £35 for a 1 kg box.

You can also create your own mix at home by buying a few different tubs and sharing them out with friends or family. Swapping unwanted sweets with others is a fun way to make sure everyone ends up with their favourites.

Prices for chocolate tubs often change a lot in the weeks before Christmas, with supermarkets regularly running offers. Comparing prices between shops and checking the price per kilo can help you find the best deal, and buying early when tubs are on offer can save money.

Check allergy information carefully, especially if you’re buying for guests, as many sweets contain nuts, milk, or wheat. When you’ve finished, check your local council’s guidance on recycling the paper wrappers and tubs, and keep chocolates somewhere cool and dry so they stay at their best.