A cheaper supermarket cheddar has come out on top in a Which? blind taste test, beating well-known names such as Cathedral City and Pilgrims Choice. The consumer group asked 75 people to try 11 extra mature cheddars without knowing which was which, and Aldi says its £2.99 Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar scored highest, with 78%. Some of the dearer own-label options did less well, and the one that came last costs about twice as much per kilo as the winner.
Which? held the tasting in September, with 75 people whose ages and backgrounds broadly reflect the UK’s adult population. Between them, they got through 32 blocks of cheese, about 10 kg in all, sitting in private booths and trying the cheeses in a different order each so that none had an unfair advantage.
The test was blind, which means nobody could see the brand or the packaging. Each cheese got an overall score that was mostly based on flavour, which counted for half, with aroma making up a fifth and appearance and texture sharing the rest.
The cheeses that came top & those that didn’t impress
According to the results published by Aldi, its West Country cheddar scored 78%, putting it just ahead of Pilgrims Choice on 76% and Waitrose’s Davidstow Cornish cheddar on 75%. Which? named three Best Buys from the test, saying they included one of the big brands and a low-cost supermarket cheddar.
Three cheeses tied on 74%, these being Cathedral City Our Extra Mature, Morrisons The Best Extra Mature Farmhouse and Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Cumbrian. Lidl’s Deluxe Somerset Crunchy, which costs the same as Aldi’s, was close behind on 73%.
Asda’s Exceptional Wyke Farms Somerset cheddar scored 72%, followed by M&S Cornish Cruncher on 70% and Castello Tickler on 69%. These are all perfectly good cheeses, but they didn’t stand out to the panel as much as the ones above them. Tesco Finest Cave Aged cheddar came last of the 11, with 66%. It’s also one of the most expensive in the test once you take the small pack size into account, which shows that paying more doesn’t always mean you’ll enjoy it more.
How the prices compare
Pack sizes vary, so looking at the price per kilo is the fairest way to compare. Using the prices Which? gave in November, Aldi’s 350g block at £2.99 works out at about £8.54 a kilo, the same as Lidl’s, while Waitrose Davidstow at £3.18 for 350g comes to about £9.09.
Morrisons The Best is about £10 a kilo and Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference is about £11.29, while M&S Cornish Cruncher and Tesco Finest Cave Aged both work out at around £17.50 a kilo. The branded cheeses vary a lot depending on where you shop, with Cathedral City ranging from £2.75 at Morrisons to £4.25 at Waitrose, and Pilgrims Choice from £2.96 at Waitrose to £5.15 at the Co-op.
Aldi’s Specially Selected West Country Extra Mature Cheddar comes in a 350g pack, and you’ll need to pop into your local store to pick it up. Prices can change, so it’s worth checking on the shelf before you go expecting a particular price.
If you’d rather stick with a big name, it pays to shop around because the same 350g block of Pilgrims Choice was about £2.19 cheaper at Waitrose than at the Co-op when Which? checked. Lidl’s cheddar is a close match on price and only a point behind on taste, so it’s a sensible pick if that’s your nearest store.
What makes a cheddar extra mature?
Extra mature cheddar is left to age for longer than mild or mature, usually between 18 months and two years. That longer ageing gives it a stronger, tangier flavour than younger cheddars.
Which? also notes that extra mature cheddar is naturally lower in lactose because of the ageing, although its nutritionist, Charlotte Phillips, says it shouldn’t be thought of as suitable for everyone. Anyone who has trouble with dairy is best checking with a GP or dietitian before relying on that.
Storing cheddar at home & how to serve it at its best
How you wrap cheese makes a real difference to how long it stays nice. Neal’s Yard Dairy, a London cheese shop, advises against wrapping cheese in cling film or foil because it can make the cheese sweat and spoil the flavour, and suggests waxed, greaseproof or baking paper instead. Keeping the wrapped cheese in a plastic box in the fridge helps stop it drying out or picking up other smells. If the cut surface goes a bit dry, Neal’s Yard Dairy says you can scrape it off or cut a thin slice away, then rewrap the rest.
Neal’s Yard Dairy says cheese served too cold can taste bland. It suggests taking cheese out a few hours before serving, keeping it wrapped while it comes up to room temperature, and only cutting what you need. That’s especially worth doing for a cheeseboard over Christmas, when an extra mature cheddar is likely to be on the table. Letting it warm up a little brings out the tangy flavour that the Which? panel was judging in the first place.
The Which? results are a useful reminder that a cheaper own-label cheese can taste just as good as, or better than, a big name or a premium range. Checking the price per kilo on the shelf label is the quickest way to see what you’re really paying. If you fancy a change, trying the top few side by side at home is an easy way to find your own favourite, as everyone’s taste is a little different and a few points between cheeses won’t matter to everyone.



