Good Housekeeping Names Gail’s Smoked Turkey Roll Best Christmas Sandwich

Andy Li, CC0

Christmas sandwiches are back on the shelves, and there are more of them than ever, from supermarket meal deals to bakery rolls costing the best part of £10. To help shoppers choose, the Good Housekeeping Institute tasted 37 festive wraps, sandwiches, and toasties from supermarkets and high street chains. Gail’s smoked turkey and Swiss cheese roll came out on top, with a vegan sandwich from Morrisons just behind it.

The Good Housekeeping Institute’s team tried 37 festive options from across the high street, including sandwiches, rolls, wraps, and toasties. Each one was given a score out of 100, with the testers looking at things like flavour, how well the sandwich held together, and the quality of the ingredients.

That last point matters more than it might sound. A festive sandwich often has more fillings than an everyday one, from stuffing and cranberry to slaw and chutney, and a sandwich that falls apart or turns soggy by lunchtime can let down even good ingredients.

The winner and the runner-up

Gail's

The top spot went to Gail’s Smoked Turkey and Swiss Cheese roll, which pairs shredded free-range turkey with Swiss cheese, bacon jam and a chipotle mayonnaise in a soft roll. It’s reported to cost £7.80, and at 771 calories, it was also the most calorific option in the test.

In second place, just two points behind with a score of 90 out of 100, was Morrisons’ Festive Onion Bhaji sandwich. It’s vegan and costs £3.40 for a 190g pack. Good Housekeeping’s testers praised its generous layers of minty dressing, mango chutney, beetroot, spinach and onion bhaji, and at 379 calories it was the lowest-calorie option they tried.

The rest of the top 10

According to the full list reported from the test, Leon’s Christmas wrap, with spiced turkey kofta, fennel slaw and cranberry and orange relish, came third at £8.95. Pret had two entries in the top five, its brie, pistachio, and cranberry baguette at £6.25 and its pigs in blankets roll at £5.

M&S’s pigs in blankets sandwich, at £4.25, was sixth, with Aldi’s Specially Selected ham and Christmas slaw bloomer seventh at £2.79. The top 10 was completed by Joe & the Juice’s Joe Ho Ho at £9.95, Asda’s Exceptional turkey, brie and stuffing sandwich at £4.40 and Waitrose’s Italian porchetta ciabatta at £4.95.

How the prices compare

The gap between the cheapest and most expensive options in the top 10 is more than £7. Aldi’s bloomer, at £2.79, was the cheapest, while Joe & the Juice’s sandwich, at £9.95, cost more than three and a half times as much.

The two highest scorers also show how much prices can vary. Morrisons’ sandwich, which scored just two points lower than the winner, costs £4.40 less than Gail’s roll. If you buy a festive sandwich a few times a week in the run-up to Christmas, choosing a cheaper option you enjoy can make a noticeable difference.

Meal deals and loyalty prices

Many supermarket festive sandwiches are included in meal deals, which can be better value if you’d buy a snack and a drink anyway. Good Housekeeping says Morrisons’ onion bhaji sandwich can be bought as part of a meal deal for £3.65 with a More card, or £4.25 without one.

That’s a good example of how loyalty schemes can change the price you pay. If you regularly shop at a supermarket with a free loyalty card, it’s worth signing up and scanning it, so you’re not paying the higher price at the till.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by 🇬🇧 (@superbritishgirl)

Checking the calories

Calories vary a lot between festive sandwiches, partly because of rich fillings like cheese, stuffing, and mayonnaise. In Good Housekeeping’s test, the winning Gail’s roll had more than twice the calories of the Morrisons sandwich.

Other lower-calorie options in the test included Costa’s Festive Flatbread at 419 calories and a Gail’s chickpea, pickled cabbage and harissa sandwich at 433 calories. Pre-packed sandwiches show the calories and other nutrition information on the label, so it’s easy to compare them in the shop.

Keeping shop-bought sandwiches safe

Pre-packed sandwiches have a use-by date, and the government’s food labelling guidance says these dates are about safety. Eating food after its use-by date could make you ill, so it’s best not to keep a sandwich past it, even if it looks and smells fine.

If you buy a sandwich to eat later, keep it in the fridge until you need it. The Food Standards Agency says fridges should be set between 0C and 5C, and that food with a use-by date should be stored in the fridge.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Zola Nene (@zola_nene)

Making your own with leftovers

A homemade sandwich with leftover turkey, stuffing, and cranberry sauce can be just as festive, and much cheaper. The Food Standards Agency says cooked food should be cooled and put in the fridge within one to two hours, and leftovers should be eaten within 48 hours or frozen.

So if you’re planning Boxing Day sandwiches, get the leftover meat into the fridge soon after the Christmas meal rather than leaving it out on the side. You could try swapping in some of the flavours from the test, such as a spoonful of chutney or a crunchy slaw, to make it feel a bit different.