Christmas dinner wouldn’t be the same for many of us without a rich, fruity pudding to finish things off, but with every supermarket selling its own version, picking one can be tricky. Plenty of shoppers head straight for Marks & Spencer, yet a new blind taste test by consumer group Which? suggests you could do better for less. Three own-brand puddings came out joint top this year, and two of them cost £5 less than the M&S option. Here’s how each one fared, along with a couple of other festive treats that impressed the testers. Christmas puddings keep well in the cupboard for months, so there’s no need to wait until the last minute to stock up.
How the puddings were put to the test
Which? gathered a panel of 70 people who enjoy Christmas pudding, chosen to broadly reflect UK adults in terms of age, gender and other factors. Each person tried luxury puddings from Aldi, Asda, Co-op, Iceland, Lidl, M&S, Morrisons, Sainsbury’s, Tesco and Waitrose without knowing which brand was which. Every tester sat in a private booth, so nobody could chat about their opinions or sway anyone else’s verdict.
The puddings were served in a different order to different people, which stops the first or last one tasted getting an unfair advantage. Each portion was 50g and heated following the instructions on the packet, just as you would at home. Scores were split four ways, with flavour making up half the total, appearance counting for 20%, and texture and aroma taking 15% each. That means a pudding needed to look and smell good as well as taste great to reach the top. Because nobody knew which brand they were eating, a big name or a fancy box couldn’t influence the results.
Asda’s pudding shares the top spot.
Asda’s Exceptional 12-Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding costs £9 for 800g and scored 75%, earning a best buy award. It’s made for the supermarket by Matthew Walker Puddings, which is said to be the oldest Christmas pudding maker in the world. Inside you’ll find vine fruits, glacé cherries, almonds, pecans and walnuts, with the sponge flavoured using French cognac and Spanish sherry. The “12-month matured” label means the pudding has been left to rest for a year after cooking, giving the flavours time to deepen and blend together.
Testers described it as indulgent and said it was absolutely packed with fruit and nuts. It was rated highly for its sweetness and moist texture, which helped it impress across the board. The alcohol and spice came through quite gently, and the vast majority of the panel were happy with that. If you prefer a pudding with a stronger kick, though, you might find this one a little too mild for your taste.
Waitrose costs more but wins plenty of fans.
The Waitrose No.1 12-Month-Matured Christmas Pudding also scored 75%, though at £14 for 800g it’s quite a bit dearer than the other two winners. Even so, the panel thought it was a fine choice for rounding off Christmas dinner, and they were impressed by how good it looked on the plate. There was no skimping on the fruit either, with plenty of raisins, currants, and cherries alongside pecans and walnuts.
Tasters loved its moist texture and rich sweetness, and they described the fruit as succulent. Around two-thirds felt the level of spice was spot on, while most reckoned the alcohol flavour was about right. A handful said they’d have liked a stronger overall taste, but complaints were few and far between. If you’re happy to spend a little extra for a special occasion, this is a safe bet. Worked out by weight, it comes to about £1.75 per 100g, compared with roughly £1.13 for the Asda and Tesco versions.
Tesco completes the three-way tie.
Rounding off the trio of winners is Tesco’s Finest 12-Month Matured Christmas Pudding, which matched the others with a score of 75%. It normally costs £9 for 800g, but Clubcard holders can currently pick it up for £7, making it the cheapest of the top three right now. The panel said it looked great and enjoyed finding lots of raisins, currants, glacé cherries, pecans, and almonds in every spoonful. Like its fellow winners, it has been left to mature for a full year.
It scored well for sweetness and moistness, although its texture wasn’t rated quite as highly as the Asda and Waitrose versions, with testers saying it wasn’t as succulent. The pudding contains brandy, cider, Amontillado sherry and cognac, a mix most of the panel liked. Some, however, said they’d have preferred a bolder spice and alcohol flavour. For anyone keeping a close eye on the festive budget, the current Clubcard deal makes it a tempting buy.
Morrisons and Sainsbury’s just miss out.
Close behind the winners was Morrisons The Best 18-Month Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding, which costs £9 for 800g and scored 71%. It features brandy-soaked cherries and generous amounts of pecans, walnuts, and almonds. Most testers loved its moist texture, and more than half said the sweetness and spice were just right. Its alcohol flavour was the strongest of the bunch, which split opinion, with half the group loving it and others finding it a bit too much.
Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference 18-Month Matured Christmas Pudding also scored 71% and costs £9.50 for 800g. Testers called it a decent choice that looked and smelled good, and they found it moist with a pleasant sweetness. Two-thirds enjoyed its festive spice, but nearly a third felt the alcohol flavour wasn’t strong enough. That was the main thing holding it back from a higher score. Both of these puddings have been matured for 18 months, six months longer than the joint winners, which shows a longer wait doesn’t always lead to a better result.
How the rest of the puddings ranked
Lidl and M&S finished level on 70%, though there’s a big gap in price. Lidl’s Deluxe 18-Month Matured Christmas Pudding costs £4.49 for a smaller 400g pud, while the M&S Collection 12-Month Matured Christmas Pudding is £14 for 907g. Lidl’s version was praised for its excellent fruit and nut content, and people liked its texture and sweetness, though many thought it lacked spice and alcohol flavour. The M&S pudding looked lovely, smelled good, and had a moist texture, but its sweet spiciness didn’t win everyone over. Gram for gram, the M&S pudding works out at about £1.54 per 100g, while Lidl’s is around £1.12.
Aldi’s Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding, priced at £6.99 for 800g, scored 69% and was reasonably well liked, although the panel was divided over its fruit and nut content. Co-op’s Irresistible 12-Month Matured Christmas Pudding (£4.25 for 400g) came next with 68%, scoring well for looks and aroma but struggling on flavour. Iceland’s Luxury 18-Month Matured Christmas Pudding, the cheapest at £4 for 400g, finished last with 64%. It gained some approval for sweetness, spice and texture, but didn’t stand out in any one area. The smaller 400g puddings from Lidl, Co-op and Iceland suit smaller households, so you’re not left with lots of leftovers. Aldi’s offering is the best value by weight among the full-sized puds, working out at under 90p per 100g, and it has been matured for twice as long as the winners.
Hot chocolate and smoked salmon winners
Which? has been running several festive taste tests, and the results for hot chocolate may please anyone who loves a cosy drink on a winter evening. Hotel Chocolat’s Classic 70% Hot Chocolate Flakes, which cost £9.95 for 280g, came out on top, beating versions from Knoops and M&S. Testers described the taste as luxurious, with a good balance of sweet and bitter and a smooth, velvety feel in the mouth. Because it comes as flakes that melt into hot milk, you can make each cup as rich or as light as you like by changing how much you add.
For smoked salmon, Asda is the place to head this year. Its Exceptional Mild & Delicate Scottish Smoked Salmon costs £4.74 for 100g and topped the test, with testers calling it a fantastic pick for festive entertaining at under a fiver. They loved its well-balanced flavour and satisfying texture, and thought the slices were just the right thickness. It even beat Mowi Smoked Salmon Slices, which cost £6 for 100g, proving the own-brand option can hold its own against bigger names. Smoked salmon is ready to eat straight from the pack, which makes it handy for a Christmas morning breakfast or quick party nibbles.



