Sainsbury’s Christmas Cake Named Best of the Year in Taste Test

Getty Images/iStockphoto

If you like to pick up a ready-made Christmas cake rather than bake your own, there’s good news for Sainsbury’s shoppers. The supermarket’s Taste the Difference Rich Iced Christmas Cake has been crowned the best of the year in BBC Good Food’s annual Christmas taste tests, beating rivals from the likes of M&S, Waitrose, Morrisons, and Tesco. Aldi took second place with its own version, and the awards also named the top choices for Christmas puddings, desserts, biscuits and panettone, giving shoppers plenty of ideas ahead of the festive food shop.

For this year’s awards, 11 supermarkets put forward their best festive products across 19 different categories. In total, 140 items were tried, with each one prepared or cooked exactly as the instructions on the packaging said, so they were tested just as shoppers would enjoy them at home. The categories covered everything from turkeys and side dishes to puddings, cakes and sweet treats.

The judges tasted everything blind, meaning they didn’t know which supermarket each product came from. They then gave every item a score out of 10 and wrote comments on anonymous forms, while an independent adjudicator kept an eye on the whole process to make sure it was fair. That approach helps ensure the results are based on taste alone, rather than brand loyalty or fancy packaging. It also means a cheaper product has just as much chance of winning as a premium one.

Sainsbury’s cake takes the top spot.

Sainsbury's

The overall winner in the Christmas cake category was the Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Rich Iced Christmas Cake, which costs £13.50 for a 900g cake. It’s due to arrive in Sainsbury’s stores across the country soon, so keep an eye out if you’d like to get one before the shelves fill up with festive shoppers. At just under a kilo, there should be plenty to go around a large family gathering.

Judges were impressed by its dense, rich texture and its strong, boozy flavour. They also praised the thick layer of marzipan and icing on top, the juicy fruit and nuts inside, and a deep brown sugar taste that really stood out. For anyone who likes a traditional, heavy fruit cake with plenty of richness, this one looks to tick all the boxes. That brown sugar note in particular helps set it apart from lighter, sweeter cakes on the shelves.

Aldi comes a close second.

Runner-up in the category was the Aldi Specially Selected Iced Rich Fruit Cake, which will also be in stores soon. It’s another win for the budget supermarket, which regularly picks up praise in festive food awards for offering quality products at lower prices. A price for the cake hadn’t been shared at the time of the results, but Aldi’s festive range usually comes in cheaper than many of its rivals.

The judges described Aldi’s cake as very dense with a generous boozy kick, and said its texture was almost closer to a Christmas pudding than a standard cake. It’s packed with fruit, including whole glacé cherries, which give it a colourful look when sliced. That could make it a great pick for anyone who loves a moist, fruit-heavy cake with plenty going on in every mouthful. Fans of glacé cherries in particular are likely to be pleased.

Christmas cake is a festive favourite with a long history.

Christmas cake has been a part of British celebrations for generations. It grew out of older festive bakes, including the Twelfth Night cake, which was eaten at the end of the Christmas season before the Victorians shifted the focus to Christmas itself. Over time, the rich fruit cake topped with marzipan and white icing became the version most of us recognise today. Decorations have changed too, with snowmen, robins and little sprigs of holly still among the most popular choices.

Many families still have their own traditions when it comes to Christmas cake, and these can vary a great deal from one home to the next. Some like to bake theirs weeks in advance, while others prefer to pick one up from the shops. In parts of Yorkshire, it’s even traditional to enjoy a slice alongside a piece of Wensleydale cheese, a pairing that might sound unusual but has plenty of loyal fans. The salty, crumbly cheese balances out the sweetness of the fruit and icing.

There were other sweet winners for the festive table.

Aldi also came out on top in the Christmas pudding category, with its Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding taking first place. It costs £7.99 for an 800g pudding, making it a good choice for anyone hosting a big family dinner on a budget. Matured puddings tend to have a deeper, richer flavour, as the fruit has had longer to soak up the spices.

If you’re after something a little more eye-catching for dessert, the best showstopper went to M&S’s Snow Much Fun Dessert, which costs £25 for 1 kg. Showstopper desserts are designed to be the centrepiece of the table, so they’re a popular choice for those who want to finish the big meal with something impressive without spending hours in the kitchen. It’s more of a treat at that price, but at 1 kg there should be enough to share around the table.

Biscuits and panettone were also picked out.

Sainsbury’s picked up more than one award this year. As well as the top cake, its Taste the Difference Shortbread Gifting Tin was named the best Christmas biscuit tin, costing £8 for 250g. A tin of buttery shortbread makes an easy present for friends, neighbours or colleagues, and it keeps well too. It’s also a handy stand-by to have in the cupboard when visitors pop round over the holidays.

In the classic panettone category, the winner was the Angela Hartnett with Waitrose Panettone Classico, which costs £25 for 750g. Sainsbury’s took second place with its Taste the Difference Classic Panettone, which will be in stores soon. That’s a strong showing for Sainsbury’s across several of the sweeter categories. Panettone is a light, sweet Italian bread studded with dried fruit, and it has become a popular alternative for anyone who finds traditional Christmas cake a little too heavy.

M&S was named the best supermarket overall.

While Sainsbury’s took the cake crown, M&S was named the best supermarket overall for Christmas 2026. The judges said this was down to the sheer number of wins it achieved across key festive categories, with top-rated products ranging from turkey to mince pies. That spread of strong results means M&S shoppers can pick up most of their Christmas essentials in one place.

It shows that there’s no single shop that does everything best, so it can pay to mix and match. You might pick up your cake from one supermarket, your pudding from another and your dessert from a third. Shopping around in this way can also help spread the cost of Christmas. Taste tests of this kind can be a handy guide if you’re trying to make the most of your budget while still putting on a spread that everyone will enjoy.

How to get the most from a shop-bought cake

Once you’ve bought your Christmas cake, store it in an airtight tin or container in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight. This helps keep the icing fresh and stops the sponge from drying out. Most shop-bought cakes come with a best before date, so check the label to see how long yours will last once opened. Wrapping any leftovers well can keep them tasty for days after the big celebrations are over.

When it comes to serving, a sharp knife dipped in hot water will help you cut neat slices through the icing and marzipan. If you’re buying for guests with allergies, have a close look at the ingredients list, as many Christmas cakes contain nuts, and some include alcohol, which may not suit everyone, including children and pregnant women. If you’re hosting, it can help to have a nut-free or alcohol-free option on the table so everyone can enjoy a festive treat.