Few things say Christmas quite like a mince pie, whether you’re leaving one out for Father Christmas, warming a couple in the oven or tucking into one with a dollop of cream. With shelves already filling up with festive boxes, a recent taste test from the Daily Express of more than 20 different packs put supermarket favourites up against bakery and luxury options to find out which are best this year. The results show that while the classics still hold their own, some of the most enjoyable pies on offer are the ones that put a new spin on the old favourite.
Despite the name, there’s no meat in a modern mince pie. The filling, known as mincemeat, is a sticky mix of dried fruit such as raisins and sultanas, along with apple, orange peel and warming spices, often with a splash of brandy or rum stirred in for extra festive flavour. It all sits inside a buttery pastry case, usually with a lid or a pastry star on top. Recipes vary a lot from one brand to the next, which is why two boxes can taste surprisingly different.
The pies in the test were tried both straight from the box and gently warmed in the oven. Each one was judged on how generous and well-balanced the filling was, the quality of the pastry, how good it looked and whether it offered decent value for money. There was a mix of classic recipes, new flavours, free-from options and mini versions, so there should be something here for every taste and budget.
The top pick for this year
View this post on Instagram
Coming out on top overall were the Waitrose No.1 Pistachio and Sour Cherry Frangipane Mince Pies, which cost £4 for a pack of four. They’re scattered with chopped pistachios and have a soft layer of frangipane, a sweet almond sponge, sitting over the filling. Instead of standard mincemeat, there’s a jammy sour cherry mix that adds a pleasing sharpness to cut through the sweet, nutty top.
Anyone who loves pistachios is likely to be a fan, though purists might feel they stray a little too far from tradition. Even so, they’re a great example of how a festive classic can be given a creative twist without losing what makes it special. They look neat and polished too, which makes them a good choice if you’re putting out a plate for guests. At £1 a pie, they also sit comfortably in the middle of the price range.
The best options on a budget
If you’re after good value, the Asda Exceptional Luxury Mince Pies cost £2.84 for six, which works out at less than 50p each. They’re generously filled, and the mincemeat is flavoured with port, orange oil and Cognac without tasting too boozy or too sweet. The pastry is a touch heavy, but it’s buttery and holds together well, making these an easy crowd-pleaser for the price.
Aldi’s Classic Mince Pies are even cheaper at £1.75 for six. They have a pretty star on top and a decent amount of traditionally spiced filling, although the pastry is quite crumbly, so they can be a bit messy to eat. They won’t match the richness of a pricier bake, but they’re handy to keep in the cupboard for unexpected visitors or a quick treat with a cup of tea.
Classic choices from familiar names
View this post on Instagram
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference All Butter Mince Pies, at £3.50 for six, look exactly as a traditional mince pie should, with a golden finish and a star on the lid. The filling is sweet and sticky with a noticeable brandy warmth, though the pastry is on the crumbly, dry side. M&S Classic Mince Pies cost £2.50 for six and are generously filled, with soft, buttery pastry and a scalloped edge, although the mincemeat is fairly mild.
Mr Kipling Signature Mince Pies, at £3.50 for four, are wider and flatter than most, with a snowflake design on a partly open top. The pastry is nicely baked and there’s plenty of fruit inside, but they’re quite sweet, so one is likely to be enough. If you prefer a gentler, less spiced flavour, the M&S pies may suit you best, while brandy fans should head for the Sainsbury’s box.
Something a little different
Tesco Finest Hand Crafted Jewelled Mince Pies, at £5 for two, were one of the standouts. They’re flat and wide, topped with almonds, walnuts, pistachios, glacé cherries and apricot, and could easily pass for florentines at first glance. The brown butter pastry has a lovely rich flavour, and the chewy, sticky filling is laced with orange liqueur and brandy without drowning out the fruit.
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Ecclefechan Tarts, at £3.50 for four, are a traditional Scottish bake named after a village in the Borders, filled with dried fruit and nuts rather than mincemeat. They’re rich and nutty without being overly sweet, and make a welcome change if you fancy a break from standard mincemeat. M&S Puff Pastry Mince Pies, at £2.50 for six, swap shortcrust for light, flaky puff pastry with a sugary top, while Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference All Butter Frangipane Pies, at £3.50 for four, have a lovely almond topping but could do with more filling.
Little bites for parties and after dinner
Waitrose No.1 Mini Brown Butter Mince Pies cost £4 for nine and have a grown-up flavour, with nutty pastry and a deep, rounded filling warmed with Cognac. Their small size makes them ideal for serving with coffee after a big meal, although anyone who likes a hefty pastry-to-filling ratio might prefer a full-sized pie.
The M&S Collection Mini Mince Pies, at £3.50 for nine, are decorated with a tiny holly leaf, so they look very festive on a party table. The pastry is buttery, but the filling is mild and there isn’t a great deal of it. Still, they’re easy to keep in the cupboard for a quick, no-fuss sweet treat when friends drop round.
Pies for a special treat
View this post on Instagram
The highest score of the whole test, a full five stars, went to the Farm Shop Mince Pies, which cost £12 for six. Handmade in Somerset, they’re classic in style but done exceptionally well, with sturdy pastry that doesn’t crumble, a richly spiced filling and a fine dusting of sugar on top. They’d make a lovely gift to take to a friend’s house over Christmas, and they’re even better warmed through slightly.
GAIL’s Mince Pie Box, at £13 for six, offers rustic, deeply baked pies with pastry somewhere between flaky and shortcrust, a gooey, well-spiced filling made with apples, cranberries and citrus peel, and a crunchy demerara sugar top. The Newt in Somerset’s Crumble Top Mince Pies were the biggest in the test, with a deep filling packed with Bramley apples and orange flavours, and a crumbly topping that adds a nice bit of texture. Their filling is a little drier than some, but the pastry stays soft, and the mincemeat was rated the tastiest of the whole line-up.
Free-from and festive extras
For anyone avoiding milk and gluten, the Waitrose Free From Mince Pies, at £2 for two, are a good option. Free-from pastry can sometimes be dry or fall apart, but these hold together well and have a satisfying bite, along with a decent amount of filling that has a bright, orangey flavour. They aren’t as light or flaky as a traditional buttery pie, but they still feel suitably festive.
Aldi’s Specially Selected Ballycastle Mince Pies, at £2.49 for four, are more of a mini Christmas dessert than an everyday snack. The filling is warmed with Cognac, brandy and cider, while the topping is flavoured with Aldi’s own Irish cream liqueur. The topping is heavy and very sweet, so they’re best enjoyed cold and one at a time, and they may feel a bit over the top for traditionalists.
Picking the right box for you
If you love trying new flavours, the Waitrose pistachio and sour cherry pies and the Tesco jewelled pies are the ones to look out for, offering something fresh while still feeling Christmassy. For a classic pie that’s sure to impress, the Farm Shop mince pies were the clear favourite, while Asda and Aldi offer the best value for anyone feeding a crowd.
Whichever you choose, warming your pies in a low oven for a few minutes can really bring out the flavour of the filling and crisp up the pastry. Just keep an eye on them, as some fillings turn very gooey if they get too hot. Checking the label is also sensible if you’re buying for someone with allergies, as many mince pies contain nuts, and several include alcohol in the filling.



