Some Brits Would Rather Have a Fancy Job Title Than a Pay Rise

Most of us would probably say we’d take more money over a more impressive job title, and a new study suggests that’s exactly what the majority of workers would do.

Getty Images

However, researchers in the US have found that one group of people is much more tempted by the title, along with public praise and recognition, and those are people who score higher on a personality trait called narcissism. The study is a useful reminder that not everyone is motivated by the same rewards at work, although it comes with a few important caveats.

Here’s what the researchers found, what it might mean for you, and how to weigh up a title against a pay rise if you’re ever offered the choice.

The study examined how workers feel about what they do every day.

Getty Images

The research was carried out by Emily Zitek of Cornell University, along with Verena Krause and Alexander Jordan, and was published in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science. Across four main studies, they asked 1,069 full-time employees in the US how they felt about different types of rewards at work, from bonuses and promotions to public awards.

The participants also filled in a questionnaire measuring grandiose narcissism, which is a personality trait linked to wanting admiration and status, rather than a mental health diagnosis. Everyone has some degree of it, so the researchers looked at how people’s choices changed as their scores went up.

Most people prefer private rewards.

Getty Images/iStockphoto

One of the clearest findings was that, overall, people prefer to be rewarded quietly rather than in front of others. In one study, workers rated private rewards as noticeably more motivating than public ones, and in another, most said they’d rather have a 10% bonus announced privately than in front of the whole company.

The researchers think this is partly because public rewards can make colleagues jealous, which can make work feel awkward. Many of us are also simply more comfortable being thanked in a one-to-one meeting than having attention drawn to us in a team meeting.

The title versus the pay rise—which came out on top?

Getty Images/iStockphoto

In the final study, workers were asked to imagine choosing between two new jobs, both needing more effort, with the same level of power and the same number of people to manage. One came with an impressive title that friends and family would admire but no extra money, while the other came with a higher salary that nobody outside work would know about.

Overall, people chose the higher pay by a clear margin, and they said they’d work much harder for a pay rise than for a better title on its own. However, the higher someone scored on narcissism, the more likely they were to choose the title and to say they’d work harder to get it.

Status really matters to some people.

Getty Images

The researchers found that people higher in narcissism tended to care more about their status among colleagues, and to worry less about making other people envious. That combination made a public reward, such as a company-wide announcement or a grand job title, feel more appealing to them.

It’s worth stressing that even people who scored highly on narcissism still generally preferred money and private rewards in absolute terms. Their preference was just weaker than everyone else’s, so it’s a matter of degree rather than a completely different set of priorities.

What the results mean for employers

Getty Images

Lots of companies use “title inflation”, where people are given grander job titles instead of, or as well as, a pay rise, partly because it costs nothing. Zitek has said the study suggests this probably isn’t the most effective way to attract or motivate staff, since most people prefer private rewards, and that it might mainly appeal to people who are higher in narcissism.

The findings also suggest that public awards, such as employee of the month, could motivate some people much more than others. A mix of rewards, including quiet thank-yous and fair pay, is likely to work better for a whole team.

There are limits to the research.

Getty Images

The studies were based on surveys and mostly imagined scenarios, so they show what people say they would do, which isn’t always what they’d do in real life. They also can’t prove that narcissism causes people to want titles, only that the two tend to go together.

All the participants were full-time workers in the US, where attitudes to public recognition may be different from those in the UK or elsewhere. The researchers say more studies in real workplaces are needed to see whether public rewards actually make some people perform better.

Which would you prefer, the pay rise or the promotion?

Getty Images/iStockphoto

If you’re ever offered a promotion with a new title but little or no extra money, it’s worth asking whether the role will genuinely help your career, for example by giving you new skills, more responsibility or a stronger CV for future jobs. A better title can sometimes help you negotiate a higher salary later, either with your current employer or a new one.

It’s also worth thinking about the extra work involved, as a bigger title often comes with longer hours and more pressure. If the workload goes up but the pay doesn’t, you may end up worse off per hour than you were before.

How to negotiate

Getty Images/iStockphoto

If you’re offered a new title without a pay rise, you’re entitled to ask whether a salary review is planned and when, and to ask for that in writing. You can also check what similar roles pay elsewhere using job adverts and salary comparison websites, so you know what’s fair.

If you’re unsure about your rights over pay or job changes, Acas offers free, impartial advice on 0300 123 1100. And if a fancy title is what genuinely makes you happy at work, that’s fine too, as long as you go into it knowing what you’re giving up.