How much you earn might feel like it’s down to your choices, your qualifications, and a bit of luck, but a huge new study suggests your genes could play a part too.
Researchers in the US looked at the earnings of 44,500 pairs of twins and estimated that genetic differences explain around 31% of the variation in pay between people. That doesn’t mean a third of your salary is decided by your DNA, though, and the study also found that twins often end up working for the same employers, which can make genes look more important than they really are. Here’s what the researchers found, what it does and doesn’t mean, and what it could imply for your own career.
Who carried out the study.
The research was carried out by economists David Card and Jesse Rothstein of the University of California, Berkeley, along with Moises Yi of the US Census Bureau, and was published in the journal PNAS. Card is one of the best-known economists in the world, and the team used official records rather than surveys, which makes the study unusually large and reliable.
They linked household records from the 2000 US Census with official wage records from 2018 to 2023, which allowed them to follow children who were aged nine to 17 in 2000 into their late twenties and thirties. Twins were identified as children in the same household born within two days of each other, and their pay was compared with that of ordinary brothers and sisters.
How twin studies work
Twin studies are a common way for scientists to try to separate the effects of nature and nurture. Identical twins share all of their genes, while non-identical twins share around half, just like ordinary siblings, but both types of twin usually grow up in the same home at the same time.
So if identical twins earn more similar amounts than non-identical twins, researchers take that as a sign that genes are playing a part. Census records don’t say whether twins are identical, so the team used a clever workaround because twins of the opposite sex can’t be identical, while around 59% of same-sex twins are estimated to be.
What the researchers discovered
As expected, twins of the same sex had more similar earnings than opposite-sex twins, and both had more similar earnings than ordinary siblings. At first, the researchers estimated that genes explained about 36% of the differences in earnings between people.
However, they then noticed that same-sex twins were twice as likely as same-sex siblings to have worked at the same place, at 11.4% compared with 5.7%. When the twins who had worked together were taken out, the estimate fell to around 31%, which the researchers consider their best figure.
Working together is the key here.
Some employers pay more than others for the same kind of work, so if twins help each other into jobs at the same firm, they’ll naturally end up earning similar amounts for reasons that have nothing to do with their genes. When the researchers removed twins who had worked together, the genetic influence on which kind of employer people worked for almost disappeared.
What remained was mostly linked to what the researchers call people’s “portable” earning power, which is the pay they would likely earn wherever they worked. This suggests that genes may affect earnings mainly through things like skills, health and personality, rather than through landing a job at a particular company.
What 31% really means
It’s important to understand that a figure like 31% describes differences across a whole population, not how much of one person’s pay comes from their genes. It also doesn’t mean that anyone’s earnings are fixed from birth because genes can work in indirect ways, for example by shaping the kind of home and opportunities children grow up with.
That leaves around two-thirds of the differences in pay explained by other things, including education, where you live, the people you know, the choices you make and plain good or bad luck. In other words, your genes might give you a starting point, but they’re far from the whole story.
What other experts say
Felix Bittmann, a researcher at the Leibniz Institute for Educational Trajectories in Germany who wasn’t involved in the study, described the design as clever and said the findings were generally trustworthy. He added that how big the genetic effect looks depends a lot on whether twins work at the same firms, and that the study can’t give a final answer on nature versus nurture.
The study also has its limits, as it only included people in steady, full-time jobs, leaving out the self-employed and some public sector workers. It was based on people in the US, where the jobs market and education system are different from those in the UK, so the figures may not be the same here.
Things to consider when comparing yourself to your siblings
If you’ve ever wondered why you and your siblings have ended up on very different salaries, this study suggests there’s no single answer. It’s worth thinking about what has really shaped your own career so far, from the qualifications you have to the people who helped you get your first job.
It’s also worth asking whether there are things you could change, such as learning a new skill, asking for a pay review or looking at what similar roles pay elsewhere. Those are the parts of your earnings that are within your control, whatever your genes might say.
How to boost your earning power
Many of the things that affect pay can be improved at any age, and the National Careers Service offers free advice on training, changing career and writing a CV, online or by phone on 0800 100 900. Checking salary comparison websites and job adverts for similar roles can also help you see whether you’re being paid fairly.
If you’re thinking about asking for a pay rise, it helps to go in with evidence of what you’ve achieved and what others in similar jobs earn. And if you’re curious about where your talents lie, a careers adviser can help you work out which direction might suit you best.



